DR 98-058
Wilton Telephone Company
Overearnings
Order Approving Procedural Schedule
O R D E R N O. 22,960
June 23, 1998
On April 20, 1998 the New Hampshire Public
Utilities Commission (Commission) issued an Order of Notice
pursuant to RSA 365:5 and 378:7 opening an investigation
into the level of earnings of Wilton Telephone Company
(Wilton). The Order of Notice scheduled a prehearing
conference for May 27, 1998 to address the issue of
temporary rates, to consider motions to intervene, and to
establish a procedural schedule. By letter dated May 18,
1998, the Commission postponed the hearing on temporary
rates to June 19, 1998.
At the duly noticed Prehearing Conference on May
27, 1998, there were no intervenors. Wilton, the Office of
the Consumer Advocate (OCA), and the Commission Staff
(Staff) agreed upon the following procedural schedule:
Staff Audit July 15 - August 12,1998
Staff Data Requests August 7, 1998
Company Data Responses August 25, 1998
Staff Testimony September 16, 1998
Company Data Requests September 30, 1998
Staff Data Responses October 14, 1998
Settlement Discussions October 21, 1998
(10:00 a.m.)
Company Testimony November 4, 1998
Staff Data Requests November 10, 1998
Company Data Responses November 18, 1998
Settlement Discussions November 23, 1998
Stipulation, if any,
to Commissioners December 2, 1998
Hearings December 15-16, 1998
Also at the prehearing conference, in accordance
with the Order of Notice, the parties and Staff stated their
initial positions. Wilton agreed that it is in a position
of overearning but opposed temporary rates. Wilton
expressed its willingness to negotiate a settlement and
belief that the above lengthy procedural schedule would not
be needed. The OCA asserted that Wilton is earning 50% more
than its allowed rate of return. The OCA proposed to set
temporary rates at current levels if the Company was willing
to use its overearnings to eliminate any increase in rates
which might otherwise result from the introduction of EAS in
its territory. Otherwise, the OCA would recommend the
Commission order an immediate reduction in rates. Staff
asserted that overearnings exist and recommended that
temporary rates be set at current levels, noting that rates
would ultimately be trued up or down appropriate at the
conclusion of the permanent rate case.
We find the stipulated procedural schedule is
reasonable and just. We encourage Staff and the parties to
work together to reach an agreement resolving the issues
raised.
Based upon the foregoing, it is hereby
ORDERED, that the procedural schedule stipulated
to by the parties and Staff is adopted to govern our
investigation in this proceeding.
By order of the Public Utilities Commission of New
Hampshire this twenty-third day of June, 1998.
Douglas L. Patch Bruce B. Ellsworth Susan S. Geiger
Chairman Commissioner Commissioner
Attested by:
Claire D. DiCicco
Assistant Secretary